Well, it turns out that I was wrong. You CAN get some of these games in Jerusalem.
One of the main importers, Hakubiyah, has a list of stores that carry their games, including the Settlers series and many others. The stores are listed on their web site, and include:
- Monster Gaming: Mercaz Rannanim, Modiin, 077-7123415
- Dani Books: Even Yisrael 3, 02-6248293
- Rosenfeld Toys: Jaffa 34, 02-6240854
- Tamir Books: Beit Hakerem 29, 02-6511926
- Liborato Books: Hapalmach 42, 02-5661311
- Books in Rechavia: Azza 34, 02-5665658
As far as I know, each importer has exclusive license for any particular game (usually a company's entire line of games), so you're not going to find the game cheaper in one store than another. Look at both sites to see the list of games that the retailers may stock. Then call ahead to see if a particular store has a particular game in stock.
If you don't know the games, email me for suggestions.
I called Rosenfeld Toys today to see if they carried Settlers of Catan (for a gift), and they let me buy it over the phone with my credit card, and then delivered it to my house after business hours completely free as an added service.